Straight to the point: is this true? Basically, are the goals we decide worth achieving worth the morals we may sacrifice along the way?
As usual, I don't know.
Where I got this question from: school, then anime. Heh, funny isn't it, that a form of cheap entertainment usually looked down upon by the general public can induce or include scholarly questions? Actually, I've found that many animes, mangas, comic books, and other "contemptible" forms of entertainment include philosophical, theological, or otherwise deep questions. Of course, the one I derive this question from is Code Geass.
Code Geass features many characters and settings, but probably the two most important characters in the first season are Lelouche and Suzaku, best friends in the day and worst enemies at night. Lelouche, a Britanian schoolboy, is the mysterious, masked head of the Black Knights, a group pledged to free an enslaved Japan and destroy the oppressive Britania. Suzaku, a Japanese student and soldier, is an Ace Pilot of the Britanian military who aims to change Britania using peaceful means from within.
So obviously Lelouche believes that in order to free and elevate the status of the enslaved Japanese, violent actions are required. Suzaku believes that a Japan gained by the bloodshed and deaths of millions isn't a Japan worth living in. Therefore, Lelouche is the epitome of utilitarianism ideas, which means he believes that the worth of an action should be judged by the end result of that action. Suzaku is the head of the deontological ideal in Code Geass, which means that as action should be judged by how moral and lawful the action itself was.
Enough rhetoric (big words). Think about these:
-Should a mother be put in jail if she stole to feed and clothe her child?
-Should a murderer be sentenced to death if he killed in war?
-Would it be right for the U.S. to bomb a whole country in order to destroy the head of a terrorist organization?
-Is it ok to sacrifice one life to preserve the well-being of many?
I'm not asking for exact answers. I suppose it depends on what kind of mind you have, if you lean more to the scientific side or the moral/lawful side. Me personally, I'm not sure which side I would choose. The easy way out would be to say that it depends on the circumstance, but I've always felt there was something more to be said.

Knowledge damns and uplifts.
Of course, how does this apply to me?
I'm not sure of that either. Maybe it's how I value my life and the life of others, and my self-sacrificing attitude. I'm pretty sure it's about my relationship issues though.
Personal question: Is deceit acceptable in a relationship?
Not only deceit of a partner or spouse, but of oneself. Any perverted man can lie about social status, wealth, intelligence, or any other factor in order to bed a girl for a night. What I mean is, would it be alright to lie to preserve or enhance a relationship?
Like this: "I'm much happier with her now than I was with 'her' before." Suppose I'm actually in a loving, sweet relationship that had a fair chance of a future (highly improbably, but this is hypothetical)? If she asked me the question and I gave that response to her, should I be labeled as a hypocritical, lying old bastard that takes advantage of women?
One more, classical: "I love you so much." We've all heard this one before. Boy meets Girl. Boy likes Girl. Fucking Boy seduces and has his way with Girl, then disappears. Please, give me more credit than that. What has happened to me once, a girl somehow fell in love with me while I only had a moderate attraction to her. Hell, I don't think I even know what love means now, much less back then. So she confesses her undying (actually sporadical) love for me. Do I tell the truth and shatter her heart, our relationship, and the friendship we had, or do I lie to make her happy and trust myself to fall in love with her eventually?
I chose the first option. I try my best to be honest, and am under the impression that a relationship based on lies will not hold in the future, much like a structure with false foundations. I totally destroyed our relationship and former friendship, and now we're basically strangers. Your typical fairytale ending of Happily Ever After.
Of course, I'm still single. That probably says a lot and nothing in and of itself.
Now I believe that even sacred marriages bear untold lies, because it's so very difficult to be completely honest with another person all the time. Humans can't even be honest with themselves. So are relationships really built on the trust that our partners are honest with us, or the trust that the lies they tell us are told for good reasons?
I'm not afraid of girls, I'm afraid of relationships. I'm single, and that will tell you a lot and nothing about me in less than 5 seconds. Was I utilitarian, believing that the relationship was doomed anyways, so I preserved my own well-being by sacrificing her happiness? Was I deontological, stating that honesty is the best policy and all that shit we tell kids? Was I self-righteous, believing that what I did at the time was the right thing?
Don't ask me, I'm not the one going through an identity crises.
"Lonely Starship" by Singindork888 on Youtube. I was impressed.
Frank Chou
No comments:
Post a Comment