"The difference in raman and varelse is not in the creature judged, but in the creature judging. When we declare an alien species to be raman, it does not mean they have passed a threshold of maturity. It means that we have." - Demosthenes, A Letter to the Framlings, in Speaker for the Dead by Orson Scott Card
Before I begin, let's give you all a definition of raman and varelse, and some other words. Apparently these words are derived from Swedish. Utlanning is the word for a foreigner from another city or country on our world, and is still considered human. Framling is the term used for a human from another world. Raman is the third, and is meant for the stranger recognized as human, but from a different species. The fourth and final term is varelse, which is reserved for any being with which we cannot communicate or understand, and therefore we cannot understand what motivates them or their purposes. They live, but we are not sure if they are intelligent or self-aware.
(By the way, I know I'm totally stealing from the book. I'm not selling anything or making money though, so it's all good. Right?)
Anyways, one of the book's main themes is the idea of truly knowing and understanding an alien race. Their culture and tradition, history and goals, motives and inhibitions, guilt and pride, failures and achievements. In short, can someone understand a raman as well as they understand themselves?
I've read this book many times, and it is a very satisfying and enlightening piece. You know me though, I always look for ways to tie what I read into my life: how does this compare to what I experience every day? This is subconscious of course, but then I consciously think to myself, "Isn't even a framling more closely related to a raman than to oneself? How can anyone completely understand anybody but themselves, even another human closely related to him or her?" I'm sure Mr. Card meant for his readers to come to this question themselves, and he gives an answer that anyone who reads this book can interpret in his or her own way.
A cynical man would say that to a lone mind, all other minds are raman at best. I used to believe this, but I've become more open now. I've seen and said, done and felt things that I know come from my understanding of others. People do not become strangers because they hide themselves from us, but because we refuse to open our minds to them.
The fact that we have to attempt to see as others see means that each person has a different perspective. This is such an obvious fact that it is overlooked. How often do people make quick judgments and prejudices against others because of age, sex, weight, race, or some other meaningless physical appearance before the subject even opens their mouth? We've all heard the saying "Do not judge a man until you have walked a thousand steps in his shoes", but how many of us really follow this. None of us do, because it is impossible. The only way we can truly understand how another person feels and why they did what they have done is if we ourselves lived their life.
In Speaker for the Dead, Mr. Card challenges this idea. I think Mr. Card argues in his book that humans can understand each other, and even raman, on higher levels through open-mindedness, empathetic intuitiveness, and a constant dedication and quest for the truth. It's really hard to explain, and I might come back and edit this post if I find a way to phrase my thoughts. (It might be easier if you just read Speaker for the Dead, since the whole book is based on the idea, but the book's not for everybody. It's a talky, philosophical book, much more so than Ender's Game.)
I'm changing my ideas now, and I'm trying to live in a way that allows me to understand others more thoroughly. It's imperative that I understand others and their plights if I wish to help them, since that's what my life goal is. I want to help others.
I've often joked to myself about how much I seem to model myself off of Andrew Wiggin. Ender the Xenocide and Speaker for the Dead combined. A product of Mr. Orson Scott Card's imagination that was given the breath of life through his story telling. I really admire Andrew, and through him Orson Scott Card.
That's enough worship and ass kissing on my part. I need some sleep.
Peace,
Frank Chou
P.S. I know I've said this before, but I want a Speaker for my death.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment